Porsche Wins Lemon Law Suit
24 March 1998
Porsche Wins Lemon Law Suit; Sports Car Manufacturer Collects More Than $18,000 From Losing ClaimantATLANTA, March 23 -- Porsche Cars North America, Inc., recently won a unanimous jury verdict in a lemon law trial in Orlando, Fla. In the process, the company collected more than $18,000 from the losing claimant to cover legal fees incurred for the case. The suit was filed by Christopher C. Mason, D.P.M., P.A. It claimed his 1991 Porsche 911 Cabriolet was a lemon due to a purported defect in its Tiptronic transmission. After a six-day trial in the Ninth Judicial Circuit Court, the jury returned a unanimous verdict in favor of Porsche, finding that the Porsche 911 in question was not a lemon and that Porsche had not breached its limited warranty or violated the Magnuson Moss Warranty Act. Dr. Mason appealed the verdict, but shortly thereafter paid Porsche $18,258.22 to settle the case and avoid a substantially higher potential attorney's fees judgment. Porsche was represented in the case by Larry Roth and Scott Powe11 of the law firm of Roth, Edwards & Smith of Orlando. SOURCE Porsche Cars North America, Inc.